Analysis of the Speech Acts in the Sermons of Imam Hasan al-Mujtaba (AS) in Response to the Fallacies of Opponents, Based on Searle's Theory
Volume 18, Issue 1, Winter 2026, Pages 1-23
https://doi.org/10.22067/jall.2026.92974.1533
zanab rahimimoghadam, Abbas Eghbali, Ruhollah saiadynejad
Abstract The application of Searle's theory of speech acts constitutes one of the fields of study in the linguistics of literary texts. This theory describes and analyzes the types of acts, namely assertive, directive, commissive, expressive, and declarative, within a purposeful text. Through its application, one can discern the linguistic techniques speakers use in their discourse. In this context, this study aims to analyze the paradigm of "good argument" within the sermons of Imam Hasan al-Mujtaba (AS), utilizing Searle's model and a descriptive-analytical method, with the objective of identifying a valuable specimen of Arabic literary heritage, elucidating the connection between linguistics and Islamic studies, and achieving a deeper comprehension of his communicative patterns in refuting the fallacies of opponents such as Mu'awiyah and his companions. Among the findings of this research is that the opponents of Imam Hasan (AS) used various fallacies such as red herring, one-sided assessment, insult, complex question, trapping, enticement, irrelevant reasons, and falsehood to derive conclusions from invalid premises affirming their beliefs regarding opposition to the Divine Word and the superiority of the Imams (AS) concerning the issue of caliphate. It has been demonstrated that the Imam (AS), by employing speech acts, responded to the intellectual slips and invalid arguments of his opponents. Overall, the high frequency of assertive acts indicates Imam al-Mujtaba's (AS) approach of adopting an advisory strategy when dealing with adversaries. The directive and expressive acts, with lower frequency than assertive acts, reflect approaches of challenge and expediency, respectively, in refuting fallacies. Furthermore, the low frequency of commissive acts proves that in discourses that can be reliably referenced and trusted through the authority of revealed speech, committing to the occurrence of a truth holds no significant place. Since declarative acts entail the announcement of a new status, they find no place in the disputes of the Imam (AS). This indicates the discourse strategy of the best dispute used by the Imam (AS) in his encounters with opponents.
Reproducing the Codes of the Poem “Likulli Imri’in Min Dahrihi Mā Taʹawwada” by Al-Mutanabbi) Based on Roland Barthes’ Code Theory
Volume 16, Issue 4, Winter 2025, Pages 1-17
https://doi.org/10.22067/jallv16.i4.2202-1107
Golafrooz Mohebbi, Ruhollah Sayadi Nejad, Amirhossein Rasool Nia, Abbas Eghbali
Abstract Structural criticism is one of the analyses that flourished in the direction of meaning generation in the 20th century following Saussure's semiotics. "Roland Barthes" - a French semiotician and theorist - is among the critics of structuralism, the importance of his theories is in the pursuit of evolution and semiotic adventure and the creation of a kind of intellectual vitality in analysis, modern criticism and the flow of structuralism. He has presented a code-based model for text analysis, beyond which, with the help of the context of the text, it is possible to analyse the structure of different texts, without the need for the presence of the author, and only with the help of the expressive language of the text. This meaning-making model, which recognizes ciphers as the voice of the text, consists of; There are hermeneutic or enigmatic codes, proiretic or active codes, meaningful or implicit codes, symbolic or confrontational codes, and cultural or referential codes. The main goal of this article is the application of Barth's analysis approach to the meaning analysis and interpretation of the written text (Lekol'' Amree Min Dahreh Ma Ta'awwda) by Motanbi, which is based on descriptive-analytical method. The result of the research shows that Barth's cryptography model shows the presence of ciphers in different parts of the body of the text, which shows a kind of semantic dispersion at the level of the text, and it can also be applied to classical poems. Revealing hermeneutic codes the poem is for the introduction of Saif al-Dawlah. Action codes. it also narrates his fighting as the main actor. Semantic ciphers and symbolic in pursuit of creating meaning for the two main and active characters of the text, Saif al-Dawlah and Mantabi, they have put two groups of good and evil in front of each other. The cultural macrocodes of the text also show its connection with the social and religious elements of power, acquisition and ideology and influence from them which is written in the final part Intertextuality with Nahj al-Balagha is used to create some kind of general information for the reader.
Examining the discourse of submission and hope to God in Surah Kahf based on Halidi's role-oriented system
Volume 14, Issue 2, Summer 2021, Pages 88-108
https://doi.org/10.22067/jallv14.i2.2207-1165
BahrAli Rezaei, Abbas Eghbali, Rouhollah Saiiady
Abstract In role-oriented linguistics, the textual meaning of the texts is the product of the connection between the text and the situation in which it is produced. The essential function of this type of view in the Holy Quran is to reveal the hidden angles of meaning in it. This type of view is necessary to prove the hypothesis that the context of the situation presented in the role-oriented system, through the precise determination of the meaning as a basic assumption in understanding, can directly affect the purpose of the verses of the Holy Quran. For example, the position of submission and hope in God in Surah Al-Kahf reveals the different aspects of recommendation from the individual, social and religious aspects. In this research, by taking the descriptive-analytical method by examining the verses of Surah Al-Kahf that mention request and hope in God, it has been tried to explain the relationship between the discourse, the position of these categories and the text, and the relationship between the three layers of the text. A situation (scope, nature, and style of speech) should be processed with the semantic layers of language (ideological, interpersonal, and textual). Among the obtained approaches is that. Compound starters (textual-structural) have the highest frequency in the subjunctive position, which shows the connection of conjunctions with the situation. Repetition in the situational context of submission and hope is manifested in several forms. Also, he observed the use of "rab" with the pronoun "na" and "y" in all three events, i.e. (the story of young men, the event of a challenge, and the story of the owners of the garden). The semantic element of this additional combination is the hope for God's mercy, in which the context of the situation plays an essential role in shaping.
Discourse Analysis of Poems of “Baeiah” by Musaab al-Abdi and “Haeiah” by Abu Firas al-Hamdani According to the Speech Acts Theory
Volume 9, Issue 17, Summer 2017, Pages 27-55
https://doi.org/10.22067/jall.v8i17.57238
Abbas Eghbali, Ali Najafi Ayouki, Razieh Nazari
Abstract Extended Abstract 1. Introduction Shiite literature is a combination of Islamic thought and ideology which involves a purposeful and coherent discourse. Shiite poetry moderately incorporates literary devices and elements of fantasy whilst adorned with poetic precepts, the most significant of which is considered the eulogies. Within the contents of such poetry, the foundation of Shiite eulogy discourse is formed by the subject of “guidance”; as a result, realism is known as one of the outstanding properties of Shiite eulogy. In the present inquiry, the authors have attempted to lay out a discourse analysis of eulogies within two poems written by famous Shiite poets, “Musaab Abdi Koufi” and “Abu Firas al-Hamdani”. These poets lived in two different historical periods; Musaab at the late Umayyad Caliphate during which, Shias were subject to severe suppression. On the other hand, Abu-Firas lived in the 4th century, a period in which Shias enjoyed more freedom. Undoubtedly, such a difference have had significant effects on their points of view in eulogies regarding the main subject of Shiism, i.e. Imamah. 2. Theoretical Framework The theoretical foundation of this study is based upon the theory of speech acts in discourse. “Discourse” is considered as a fairly new term in linguistics which incorporates a set of texts that are linked together. As any text entails the information put forth by humans, the world of discourse mainly involves the entire events that are linked together in a social or lingual group. Given the discussion of eulogies in the present study, it can be pointed out that the discourse of the study is literary, with a distinctive feature of creativity in imparting poetic messages. Similar to any human action, the position of language in analyses based on the speech acts theory is examined through the types of human actions realized by words and sentences. This theory was put forth by the prominent figure of language philosophy, John Austin. In his view, verbs are divided into two categories of “propositional” and “performative”. Then, John Searle expanded the theory offering a more diverse categorization for utterances which included: declarative, persuasive, accrual, emotional and statement. 3. Methodology In general, by using the descriptive-analytical method within the framework of speech acts theory, the present study seeks to answer the following questions: What concepts constitute the speech acts present in these poems? In which of these poets’ speech acts, details are of more importance? Which of these poets’ speech acts involve more distinguished frankness of expression? 4. Discussion and Findings In the poems examined in this study, poets have employed four speech acts; first are the declarative speech acts which include the poets’ own beliefs regarding the accuracy of their propositions. Through persuasive speech acts, the poets have attempted to influence the audience, persuading them to do something or vice versa, using imperative verbs, commendations, or questions. Using accrual speech acts, they have tried to demonstrate and highlight the certain promises concerning the fate of the ones who do not believe in the legitimacy of Imamah. The emotional speech acts of the poets in these eulogies are full of their diverse affections toward Imams. Therefore in the poems of “Musaab Abdi” and “Abu Firas al-Hamdani”, there are a myriad of verbs based on attention and intercession. 5. Conclusion • The Concepts of “waiting and confidence” constitute the main theme of the speech acts used in both poems. • In his declarative speech act, “Musaab Abdi” have used a set of literary devices to illustrate concepts such as taking precautions, longing for union, and failure; while the environment of Abu Firas’s declarative speech acts were filled with comfort and confidence. • In his persuasive speech acts, “Musaab” highlights the concept of waiting once more as well as reminding the legitimacy of Imamah using historical intertextuality. Abu Firas on the other hand, chose to have a direct dialogue with the obstinate and attempts to highlight the inaccuracy of their beliefs and persuade them to accept the truth using verbs which entail notions such as humiliation and reprimand. • The accrual speech acts in both examined poems attempt to confirm and assure the certainty in the occurrence of the divine torment to the obstinate. • The emotional speech acts of Musaab and Abu Firas are divided into two parts; the first is concerned with immortality which is shown as the symbol of quenching one’s thirst. In the second part, Musaab asserts the aspects of hope and submission to revenge, while Abu Firas have attempted to introduce himself as one of the guided. • In comparing the speech acts in the examined poems, the privacy of expression in Musaab’s various speech acts demonstrate the stifle space of Umayyad Caliphate whereas the frankness of expression in Abu Firas’s work shows the free political environment of his period.
Eloquence in the Imagery of Nahjul-Balagah
Volume 7, Issue 12, Summer 2015, Pages 31-50
https://doi.org/10.22067/jall.v7i12.49809
abbas eghbaly
Abstract Image or artistic picture represents an imaginative process that give artistic meaning to speech. This is a process that uncovers hidden meaning and conveys the mental concepts of the writer to the audience and makes his intended meanings much deeper. The reflections of the use of this literary device in classical Arabic works and the high frequency of their use in The Holy Quran and in Nahjul-Balaghah shows the status of this technique in the literature of the old times. This paper takes a quick glance at the use of the technique of imagery in Arabic and in the Holy Quran. Then it explores the eloquence of Imam Ali’s (p.b.u.h) speech in Nahjul-Balaghah in the light of the use of imagery. Example images used in this classical work for the description of religion, piety, and mistakes are used to explain how the behavior of people with favoritism during the reign of Othman is depicted. The study indicates that Imam Ali (p.b.u.h) uses images from the moving and the stagnant aspect of nature to make the intangible more tangible and to add to the eloquence of his speech.
Auditory Images in Mu’allaghat sab’
Volume 1, Issue 1, Winter 2010
https://doi.org/10.22067/jall.v1i1.3008
Dr.Abbas Eghbali Abbas Eghbali
Abstract The Poet is considered a sculptor, a painter and a musician who dramatizes his thoughts and visions through the technique of his poetry. Mu’allaghat Sab’ – as a part of classic Arabic literary masterpieces – display this aspect brightly. These works represent a wonderful variety of images among which the sensory images – including visual, auditive and tactile images – are very common. This article explores the auditory images of pre – Islamic odes and attempts to show that – besides the use of onomatopoeia – the pre – Islamic poets used different phonological features and auditive images frequently and successfully. Along with the visual images of various colors and smelling pictures of odors, they created dynamic auditory images of natural and not natural sounds in order to bridge the gap between the world of thoughts and visions and the real world. Key words: auditory images, sensory images, Mu’allaghat sab, pre – Islamic poetry.
